AfternsAfterns
Up or down this time?Jan 13 estimated
0%0%

···

Progressive Corporation (The) (PGR) earnings date & stock reaction

Progressive Corporation (The) · Financials

ReportedOct 14 · pre-marketEPS $4.6(est $4.37)+5.3% beat· Rev $21.9B
Positives
  • ▲Solid Growth in Premium Revenue
    • Net premiums earned for the quarter were $21.87 billion, an increase of 5% vs last year.
    • Policies in force for Personal Lines reached 39.24 million, up 6% vs last year.
  • ▲Improved Underwriting Efficiency
    • The combined ratio for the quarter was 88.7%, improving by 0.8 percentage points vs last year's 89.5%.
    • The loss and loss adjustment expense ratio remained stable at 67.2% for the year-to-date period.
  • ▲Strong Earnings and Capital Efficiency
    • Net income for the quarter was $2.54 billion, demonstrating robust profitability.
    • The trailing 12-month return on average common shareholders' equity reached 34.4%.
Concerns
  • ▼Decline in Net Income and EPS
    • Year-to-date net income was $2.54 billion, down 3% vs last year's $2.62 billion.
    • Diluted earnings per share were $4.37, a decrease of 2% vs last year's $4.45.
  • ▼Investment Portfolio Losses
    • Total net realized losses on securities were $231 million for the quarter, compared to a $138 million gain vs last year.
    • Net unrealized losses on fixed-maturity securities reached $3.46 billion, indicating increased asset volatility.
  • ▼Slowdown in Commercial Lines
    • Net premiums earned in the Commercial Lines segment declined by 2% vs last year on a year-to-date basis.
Based on the Oct 14, 2026 earnings release.
Next earningsWed, January 13 (estimated)

Price after the latest report

Reported October 13, 2026how the stock moved around it
Next-day move
+1.2%
Price around earnings
Around this report
Overlapped CPI releaseA major data release (CPI, jobs) came out around this report. On those days the whole market moves, so the reaction may be mixed with the data.

Progressive Corporation (The) (PGR) rose the day after earnings in 5 of its last 12 reports (42%), moving ±1.0% on average. It has fallen despite beating the consensus estimate 4 times.

Up next day
5/12
42%
Fell despite growth
6/12
Good earnings ignored
Price when beating
+0.4%
avg over 9 beats
Price when missing
-0.6%
avg over 3 misses
Avg earnings move
±1.0%
typical swing on earnings
Biggest single move
+3.3%
'24.5 · largest reaction
🔑What actually moves this stock?

Even when EPS beat expectations, the stock fell 4 of the last 9 times. The number alone doesn't move it.

What really matters here
Whether payouts+costs stayed below premiums (under 100% = profit)
In finance terms: Combined ratio
What to watch next report

When results drop, check the metric above vs last quarter and whether guidance beats expectations.

The real bar for this stock

Beating estimates isn't enough. Here's where the real surprise started.

Beat consensus 9 of 12 times
Median beat +10%. 4 of those beats still fell the next day.
Reports that rose beat by +14.6% (median). Reports that fell beat by just +5.3%
Roughly +14.6% was the bar this stock had to clear.

How this stock reacts to earnings

Traits seen across its recent earnings reactions

Beating estimates doesn't always lift it
Up the next day 5 of 9 beats (56%)
Reaction is erratic and hard to predict
Avg +0.4% on a beat, -0.6% on a miss
Big earnings-day moves tend to fade within days
Reversed the day-one move · 64% of last 11
vs Financials sector avg (202 peers)
This
+0.1%
Sector
+0.3%
Avg next-day reaction

Earnings number vs guidance: which drives it?

How often the beat/miss matched the actual price move

This stock mostly moves with the reported earnings number
Moved opposite to results 4 of last 12 times (33%)
4xBeat but fell
Even a beat sells off if guidance disappoints
0xMissed but rose
Even a miss rebounds if guidance reassures
Fell despite growth6/12

4/9 beats fell next day · watches Combined ratio

Next-day reaction
  • Sep 2026 report+1.2%
  • Jun 2026 report-0.5%
  • Mar 2026 report-0.0%
  • Dec 2025 report-0.1%
  • Sep 2025 report-1.1%
  • Jun 2025 report+0.2%

Earnings timeline · bars = next-day move, ▲▼ = beat/miss

Jul–Sep 2026 results
Reported 2026-10-13
Next-day move
+1.2%
After 5 days —
EPS consensus $4.41 → $4.60 ▲ +4.2% beat
Price around earnings
Around this report
Overlapped CPI releaseA major data release (CPI, jobs) came out around this report. On those days the whole market moves, so the reaction may be mixed with the data.

Earnings trend · last 12 quarters

EPS$4.60YoY +14%
'24.2'26.10
Revenue—
'24.2'26.10

Earnings history and price reaction

Progressive Corporation (The) across its last 12 earnings reports: EPS versus consensus, the move on the earnings day, and the cumulative move five trading days later.
Quarter endedReported (ET)vs market expectation (consensus)Earnings dayAfter 5 days
9/20262026-10-13+4.2%+1.2%—
6/20262026-08-03+0.3%-0.5%+1.9%
3/20262026-05-04+1.6%-0.0%-2.7%
12/20252026-03-02+5.3%-0.1%-1.4%
9/20252025-11-03-19.7%-1.1%+5.5%
6/20252025-08-04+10.0%+0.2%+2.3%

12 reports, quarters ending 12/2023 to 9/2026. The earnings-day move is the first trading day that reflects the report; the five-day figure is the cumulative move from that point.

Frequently asked questions

When is the next Progressive Corporation (The) earnings date?

The next Progressive Corporation (The) (PGR) earnings report is expected Wed, January 13 (estimated). This is an estimate based on past reporting dates, not a confirmed date.

Does Progressive Corporation (The) (PGR) stock usually go up after earnings?

Over the last 12 earnings reports, the stock rose on 5 of them (42%). The average move on earnings day was ±1.0%.

Does Progressive Corporation (The) react more to the earnings numbers or to guidance?

In 4 of the last 12 reports (33%), the stock moved the opposite way from whether it beat or missed the forecast. A high share means guidance and expectations drive the move more than the reported numbers.

Can Progressive Corporation (The) stock fall even when earnings are good?

Yes. In 6 of the last 12 reports, Progressive Corporation (The) fell on the earnings day despite growing EPS. Expectations already priced in, or guidance, can matter more than the reported numbers.

Does Progressive Corporation (The) stock keep moving after the earnings day?

Over the last 11 reports, the move continued in the same direction for the following five trading days 36% of the time. This tendency is known as post-earnings announcement drift.